On Sunday, Nov. 2, Rev. V. Gene Robinson, an openly gay man, was appointed to the office of Bishop for the Episcopal Church of New Hampshire, marking a historical event for mainline Protestantism in America. News of this unprecedented event has sparked a variety of reactions throughout the Christian community.
Whether each member of the Christian community agrees with Robinson's appointment or not, most seem to have an opinion on the matter.
"The courage displayed by the Episcopal leadership should be commended," said Rev. Gloria Fish of St. Stephen's Episcopal Church in Niagara Falls. "This step is an important one for the continued inclusion of all God's people in the larger Church body."
While the questions regarding the meaning of alleged anti-gay passages in the Bible remain unanswered, conservative denominations support the notion that the scripture denounces all homosexual activities.
More liberal denominations hold that those debated passages are referring to specific instances of homosexual and or immoral behavior.
According to Seth Pearson, program director of the Episcopal Campus Ministry, the teachings of the Episcopal Church are based on scriptural analysis and traditional moral interpretation.
"As Episcopalians, we study the scripture through tradition and reason. We are trendsetters because we don't let ourselves be influenced by popular culture and we don't back away from different ideals," said Pearson. "Rev. V. Gene Robinson's sexual orientation does not hinder his Christianity or his ability to be a good bishop."
While some members of the Episcopal Church remain supportive of the executive decision to appoint an openly gay Bishop, other sects of Christianity are more sensitive to the issue of homosexuality.
"The Catholic Church is tolerant of homosexuals because we have a long history. Although the (Church) doctrine is anti-gay, pastorally we are welcoming to homosexuals, which is standard for most mainline religions," said Father Patrick Kelcher of the Newman Center Catholic Campus Ministries. "However, if a Catholic priest were openly gay, they would be suspended, especially in light of the recent scandals."
While the arguments continue about Robinson's appointment as a high-ranking church official, individuals like Kristen Perry, a junior communication major, believe the nature of the debate will lend to the improbability of its resolution.
"There can be no agreement or conclusion to these debates because we cannot go back in time to assess the intent of whoever wrote the Bible," she said. "Therefore, we must assume that there is no right or wrong in regards to homosexuality. It is simply a matter of choice and should not be judged."
Richard Zanxo, a fall 2002 UB graduate who majored in business management, shares the sentiments of those who disagree with the appointment of Robinson as a Church official.
"The act of homosexuality is said by the Bible to be a sin," said Zanxo. "This is not an interpretation, this is a fact. It has only become an interpretation within the last twenty years. This may mean that society is more liberal and accepting of gays. It does not mean that the Church, regardless of what denomination, should be represented by a homosexual."
Robert Levine, a senior business major, said he sees the Church's acceptance as nothing but positive.
"The appointment of Bishop Robinson beautifully demonstrates the Christian conviction that when two people love each other and commit their lives to each other - regardless of race, class or gender - their God lives," he said.
Photo: Courtesy of Laron Fomby
